As I write this, my thoughts turn again to the excavation at Max Gate’s front door. It is July 2022, and I’m hammering a piece of drainpipe into the wall of a trench, while, above me, a National Trust guide tells the story of Thomas Hardy and his first wife Emma. Through an open window, the sound of a Victorian melody, played on a piano, drifts across the garden.

In August 2024, after 38 years, I retired from the National Trust as their archaeologist in Wessex, covering Dorset, Somerset, Wiltshire, and Gloucestershire. I thought retirement would give me time to catch up on all sorts of things. Particularly the final publication of some of the excavations I’ve been involved with, including investigations at Corfe Castle. I was warned that retirement can turn out to be very busy. There are the grandchildren of course, and I was persuaded to be Editor of the Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History & Archaeological Society – the annual county journal for Dorset. Through this monthly column I will share some of the stories recorded within the ‘Proceedings’ and some that have yet to reach its pages.

Originally known as the Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History & Antiquarian Field Club, within its pages, in addition to articles on nature, literature, local history and geology, are the archaeological discoveries from almost 150 years. For its first volume, published in1877, Dorset dialect poet William Barnes wrote A British Earthwork, a poem promoting the value of archaeology and the need for its conservation (Blackmore 2019).

Thomas Hardy standing by his 'Druid Stone' discovered during the building of Max Gate, it now sits in its gardens. Thomas Hardy standing by his 'Druid Stone' discovered during the building of Max Gate, it now sits in its gardens. (Image: Dorset Museum & Art Gallery) The Dorset Natural History & Archaeological Society is affiliated with Dorset County Museum. Founded in 1845, this was Dorset’s first conservation body, bringing together those who opposed Isambard Kingdom Brunel’s plans to drive his railway through Poundbury hillfort west of Dorchester and Maumbury Rings to the south.

Thomas Hardy was a member of the Society, and in 1884 he lectured to an audience at Dorset County Museum. Hardy described the archaeology which was being revealed during groundworks for the house which he had designed and was currently being built by his father and brother (Hardy 1890, 78-81). His new home was called Max Gate, named after Henry Mack who, for many years, had manned the neighbouring toll gate on the Dorchester to Wareham road.

Hardy was to write many of his most famous novels at Max Gate including Tess of the d’Urbervilles and Jude the Obscure as well as some of his best poetry.

The paddock excavation in the grounds of Max Gate in July 2022, cleaning chalk to reveal enclosure pits. The Festival of Archaeology marquee is in the background. The paddock excavation in the grounds of Max Gate in July 2022, cleaning chalk to reveal enclosure pits. The Festival of Archaeology marquee is in the background. (Image: National Trust) In the 1880s, this land bordering the Wareham Road had just been taken out of the old arable fields of Dorchester and made available for development. Elegant, detached villas were being constructed on the plot. Agriculture had ploughed flat and hidden the archaeological evidence here until the foundation trenches for Hardy’s house were dug and skeletons started to be exposed. A huge sarsen stone was discovered over burnt bones while landscaping the new garden. Hardy had this erected on the edge of his lawn and called it his ‘Druid Stone’; he later celebrated in the poem The Shadow of the Stone, published in 1917.

Hardy spoke of his archaeological discoveries to his numerous visitors; people like George Bernard Shaw and T.E. Lawrence, often mentioning his ‘Roman soldiers’ unearthed while laying his entrance drive. There were certainly extended Roman burials (a couple more were found in 2014 when a new service trench was dug), but also pre-Roman inhumations typical of the Late Iron Age. These are known as ‘Durotrigan’ burials, distinctive in Dorset, crouched in an oval grave with pottery vessels and often a joint of meat for sustenance, presumably for the journey to the afterlife. Hardy used the memory of these discoveries in his 1886 novel The Mayor of Casterbridge. In this short excerpt, he describes the evidence for Roman archaeology around Dorchester (Casterbridge) as he had experienced it during the creation of Max Gate.

‘It was impossible to dig more than a foot or two deep about the town fields and gardens without coming upon some tall soldier or other of the Empire… He was mostly found lying on his side, in an oval scoop in the chalk, like a chicken in its shell; his knees drawn up to his chest.’ (The Mayor of Casterbridge, Chapter 11)

The paddock excavation in the grounds of Max Gate in July 2022, cleaning chalk to reveal enclosure pits. The Festival of Archaeology marquee is in the background. The paddock excavation in the grounds of Max Gate in July 2022, cleaning chalk to reveal enclosure pits. The Festival of Archaeology marquee is in the background. (Image: National Trust) These discoveries were glimpses of something far more exciting.

In the 1980s, during the creation of the Dorchester by-pass, Wessex Archaeology carried out archaeological evaluations on the land west of Max Gate. Archaeologists found a near perfect 100m diameter semi-circle of pits and ditches, some containing large sarsen stones over human burials; in others, the walls of the chalk cut pits had been inscribed with rare Neolithic line patterns.

Radiocarbon dating suggested that most had been dug in the Middle Stone Age about 3400-2900 BC. This made the enclosure contemporary and closely comparable with the earth bank and ditch enclosing Stonehenge. Other evidence, including pottery and C14 dates (carbon dating), suggested that it had also been occupied up to 500 years earlier, when the earliest farmers arrived in the Dorchester area and began to till the land.

In 1988, when the by-pass was built, it seemed that this rare Neolithic site had been destroyed, but was it totally lost? Looking again at Wessex Archaeology’s site plan, surely the semi-circle of pits and ditches were once part of a complete circle. If this was true, then the east half of that circle still survived under Max Gate.

Half sectioned Neolithic pit in the paddock at Max Gate. Half sectioned Neolithic pit in the paddock at Max Gate. (Image: National Trust) Following his death in 1928, Hardy’s sister Kate made sure that Hardy’s architectural creation and writing powerhouse survived as a legacy to his life and work. In 1940, on her death, she bequeathed Max Gate to the National Trust (NT). Though the gift was accepted, the NT’s architectural specialists were not hugely impressed with the building. So, it was let to tenants until a decision was made about its future. Over time, its importance was realised and since the 1990s Max Gate has been open to the public, drawing Hardy enthusiasts from around the world to Alington Avenue.

In 2019, Freya Bohea was commissioned to research and write a conservation management plan for the property. This brought together all the available information on the house and grounds. A strong recommendation in the document was for the land to be designated as a Scheduled Monument. As the National Trust’s archaeologist for Dorset, I pressed for this recognition of Max Gate as a nationally significant archaeological site, but Historic England needed evidence.

Surely, Thomas Hardy’s discovery of the ‘Druid Stone’ supported the idea of a fully circular Neolithic pit and ditch enclosure? But non-invasive techniques, like aerial photography and geophysical survey, did not reveal the buried archaeology. We would need to dig to prove it.

Detail of pit with Neolithic red deer antler pick gouge marks visible in the chalk and grey soil at the bottom of trench with charcoal revealing C14 date c.3700-3500 BC. Detail of pit with Neolithic red deer antler pick gouge marks visible in the chalk and grey soil at the bottom of trench with charcoal revealing C14 date c.3700-3500 BC. (Image: National Trust) A week was set aside during Festival of Archaeology in July 2022 and, with the help of a skilled team of volunteers, we cut the turf in the paddock and volunteers sifted the topsoil into wheelbarrows. Objects in the ‘finds’ trays ranged from plastic bottle tops and fragments of Victorian teacups to Tudor mixing bowls, medieval cooking pots and Romano British tableware; more importantly, fragments of prehistoric flint were also a common find.

The old ploughing had scraped away everything down to the white chalk bedrock, but once this was cleaned, circles of darker soil could be seen. Professor Alice Roberts visited us with the BBC’s Digging for Britain team to film the excavation and spotted these circles as archaeologically significant. We took Alice around to the front door and showed her the ditch we had found below Hardy’s gravel drive. These features coincided with the line of the proposed Neolithic enclosure. The ditch to the south, and the pits on the north, followed the trajectory of the features found by Wessex Archaeology in the 1980s; but apart from the odd piece of struck flint, there was nothing to date them.

For this reason, I hammered black plastic tubes into the filling of the ditch below Thomas Hardy’s front drive. The lack of finds made me resort to a scientific technique I’d used to date the Cerne Abbas Giant - optically stimulated luminescence or OSL. You collect the soil in a dark tube, keep the light from it, and then, in laboratory dark room conditions, measure its radiation content. This reveals how long the soil has been buried based on surviving sunlight evidence locked in quartzite crystals.

Grave goods found in a Roman burial during the building of Max Gate, with Thomas Hardy’s notesGrave goods found in a Roman burial during the building of Max Gate, with Thomas Hardy’s notes (Image: Courtesy of Dorset Museum & Art Gallery/Dorset History Centre.) In the paddock, on the opposite side of the proposed enclosure, north of Max Gate, we dug deep into one of the large pits, and, at 1.5m deep, we started to see evidence of many small, hollowed gouges in the chalk – possibly pick-axe marks made by the impact of red deer antlers. A goosebump moment, as this form of digging was typical of the Neolithic. After a gap of 200 generations, the 21st century digger is suddenly faced with the work of his predecessor.

These marks were not enough to date the pit. I needed something organic, like a discarded antler for a radiocarbon sample. Unfortunately, the lower pit filling consisted entirely of chalk rubble, and time was running out. Then, great relief, the soil at the bottom of the pit turned dark grey, tiny fragments of charcoal could be seen. These were gathered into plastic sample bags, labelled and sent for analysis.

The first C14 sample was rejected ‘insufficient carbon to date’ but the second hit the dating target 3700-3500 BC. The soil from both OSL tubes confirmed the site as Early Neolithic. We now had the proof. I wrote the report on the discoveries and sent the evidence to Historic England. Following a visit to the site by their listings officer, we waited for the decision. The final confirmation rested with the Department of Culture Media and Sport (DCMS), and this had been delayed by the General Election.

Grave goods found in a Roman burial during the building of Max Gate, with Thomas Hardy’s notesGrave goods found in a Roman burial during the building of Max Gate, with Thomas Hardy’s notes (Image: Courtesy of Dorset Museum & Art Gallery/Dorset History Centre.) There was still no news when I retired from my post as Wessex Regional Archaeologist for the National Trust, but a week later, in early September, DCMS designated the garden and paddock of Max Gate as a Scheduled Monument. This legally protects the rich archaeology that lies beneath the grounds of Thomas Hardy’s house. It also demonstrates that this is a nationally significant place, not only for its link with Hardy, but also for something created almost 6000 years earlier.

The designation was a great outcome for the National Trust team who care for this property. The ‘Druid Stone’ site, first discovered by Thomas Hardy in the 1880s, then half excavated by Wessex Archaeology a century later, was indeed a circular enclosure and continues under the flower beds and lawns at Max Gate.

Max Gate is a Grade I listed building, and now its grounds are a Scheduled Monument. Something that would have delighted Hardy. However, Max Gate is a small part of something much larger. Dorchester is at the centre of one of the greatest archaeological landscapes in the country. I will tell you more about that next month. 

Max Gate reopens to the public in mid-March 2025 check dates at nationaltrust.org.uk/visit/dorset/hardys-house-max-gate

The front elevation of Max Gate, the house Thomas Hardy designed and had built in the 1880s which sits over part of a Neolithic circular enclosure. The front elevation of Max Gate, the house Thomas Hardy designed and had built in the 1880s which sits over part of a Neolithic circular enclosure. (Image: National Trust) Further reading

Blackmore, J., 2019, ‘Language in the Landscape: an excavation of William Barnes’ “A British Earthwork”, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History & Archaeological Society, Vol. 140, 42-52.

Hardy, T., 1890, ‘Some Romano-British Relics found at Max Gate, Dorchester’, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History & Antiquarian Field Club, Vol. XI , 78-81.

Smith, R., Healy, F., Allen, M., Morris, E., Barnes, I. & Woodward, P., 1997, ‘Excavations Along the Route of the Dorchester By-pass, Dorset, 1986-8’, Wessex Archaeology 11, 27-48

Dorset Natural History & Archaeological Society 

If you have a keen interest in the county’s history, then why not join the Dorset Natural History & Archaeological Society. Members receive a free digital copy of the Proceedings every year, and the Museum library contains a complete set which you can view. There are plans to digitise the entire collection and share them on the Museum website. Yearly membership costs £35 students (over 18 in fulltime education), £60 single, £80 two adults. Your membership includes:

Free entry to the museum and all exhibitions

Two complimentary one-day admission tickets

Invites to member events and activities

Priority access and discounts on selected events

10% discount on museum shop and café

Free entry to our six Wessex Museum partners

Library access to the Museum’s reference lending library

More details at dorsetmuseum.org/get-involved/become-a-member/