At 55m the priapic chalk figure of the Cerne Giant, cut into steep downland in the heart of Dorset, is an arresting site. Located beside the Sherborne road (A352), a little to the north of Cerne Abbas village, every year, many thousands of motorists pull into the layby, read the display board, look at his chalk outline on the hill and wonder. Why was he made? Who is he supposed to be? And when was he created?

His right arm holds a club above his head, and the left arm is outstretched. Many think the Giant is a representation of the Roman god Hercules, the shape of his club would certainly fit that supposition. However, if he is Hercules, the extended arm should hold a cloak or lion’s skin, but this is missing or perhaps it is lost.

My first visit to the Cerne Giant was in 1993 when I attended a meeting about his nose. Did he ever have one, and should he have one again? Eventually, the decision favoured the nose, and a small mound of chalk was created. The papers loved it. Anything to do with the Giant is a media event. He is the rude man of central Dorset, an advertiser’s dream. Over the years, white paint and white tape have been used to deface him in various ways. His image has been used to promote …condoms, Movember (where he sported a moustache for a day), Women’s Health Day, and once, an image of Homer Simpson throwing a doughnut towards him... hoopla style.

Martin Papworth drawing the archaeological details revealed in the trenches during the excavation of the Cerne Giant in March 2020 Martin Papworth drawing the archaeological details revealed in the trenches during the excavation of the Cerne Giant in March 2020 (Image: Nancy Grace) In 1996, Katherine Barker organised a group of Bournemouth University students to tape out a female companion for the Giant. The design showed the figure striding towards the Giant carrying his cloak. The Giant’s companion was created to coincide with a conference in the village hall at Cerne Abbas to debate the date of his creation. The experts presented their evidence, and members of the audience were asked to vote.

Was he prehistoric, Roman or 17th century?

It seemed that there was no way of knowing. The Giant was unique and made of chalk. There were no dateable artefacts likely to be recovered from any excavation at that time. His earliest historical appearance is in a document dated November 1694, when Cerne’s church warden accounts recorded the cost of his repair.

There was a scientific technique which might supply a date for him; this had been pioneered at another National Trust site, the Uffington White Horse in Oxfordshire. Here, Simon Palmer and David Miles had used optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) to provide a date. This technique measures the time that has elapsed since a soil has been buried, blocking the radiation from the sun. At Uffington, this soil analysis provided a late prehistoric construction date, about 3000 years ago.

Looking down the centre of the Giant towards the excavations across the bottom chalking lines of the right and left feet. Looking down the centre of the Giant towards the excavations across the bottom chalking lines of the right and left feet. (Image: Martin Papworth) I asked Simon Palmer to create a research proposal for me, and by 1998 it was ready to take to the National Trust. The property manager at that time turned it down saying that the proposals were too expensive, adding that wasn’t the Giant’s mystery part of his appeal? A fair point. And there are many demands on limited resources. But in archaeology there is always that need to know, and after all, we now had the scientific ability to date him.

The Cerne Giant had been given to the National Trust by the Pitt Rivers family in 1920. In 2019, as the centenary year of its acquisition approached, I dusted down the research document and approached Hannah Jefferson, general manager of the West Dorset properties for the National Trust. She was very supportive, thinking that the OSL dating research would be an ideal central theme for the centenary celebrations. The results would be announced at Cerne Abbas village hall in July 2020, coinciding with the anniversary month of the original transfer of ownership.

In the autumn of 2019, I met environmental archaeologist Mike Allen on site. The Giant had been re-chalked in August – this happens roughly every decade - and subsequent heavy rain had washed some of the newly compacted chalk down his legs and arms. Puddles of white silt had accumulated at his feet and elbows, and in places the material had washed over them and continued downslope.

Professor Phillip Toms of Gloucestershire University collecting a OSL sample from the Giant's right foot trench. Professor Phillip Toms of Gloucestershire University collecting a OSL sample from the Giant's right foot trench. (Image: Martin Papworth) We could see that this process had happened after previous chalkings, and over time this had created platforms of material. Photographs were taken and we walked along the River Cerne to the pub where, over lunch, we pencilled out a research plan. Four narrow trenches should be dug through these earthwork platforms, two at his feet and two at his elbows. These would enable the construction phases of the Giant to be recorded across the chalk figure where samples for soil analysis could be collected.

Scheduled Monument consent was obtained from Historic England, and a SSSI licence granted by Natural England. When all was in place the work began.

Normally, an excavation on an exposed Dorset hillside might be delayed until the summer, but if the date was to be announced in July, then we needed to begin in March. Though the winter of 2019/20 had been very wet and windy, the weather during the dig was kind to us.

March 2020, the excavation of the four trenches at the Giant's feet and elbows, done just before lockdown. March 2020, the excavation of the four trenches at the Giant's feet and elbows, done just before lockdown. (Image: Martin Papworth) For the excavation, we had set aside five days, March 16th to 20th. This was just enough time we thought, but already, on that first day, as we carried our tools over the boundary fence and onto the outline of the Giant, Covid 19 was approaching. Four people digging four trenches, socially distanced, while the world began to shut down. Each day as I drove to work, new Covid announcements were being made. As we dug deeper, many of the people scheduled to visit us, gave their apologies and stayed away.

We excavated through the remembered re-chalkings of 2019, 2008 and 1995, then the two gravel chalk projects of 1978 and 1956. Half a metre down and chalking dates became uncertain. There were thin bands of chalk, possibly the repairs by Stuart Piggott following the necessary neglect during World War II; beneath that, a repair of the 1920s, just after the Giant’s acquisition by the National Trust.

The layer below this might be attributed to 1908 when the workman extended the Giant’s manhood by merging his penis with his navel. Then a deep deposit of chalk rubble; a belt and braces chalking perhaps managed by the great archaeologist General Pitt Rivers in 1887. Below this, there were no historical clues; bands of chalk paste, compacted chalk and below these, another deep rubble chalk layer that filled a trench cut into the natural chalk.

National Trust staff and volunteers rechalking the Giant in August 2019. The Giant is usually rechalked every decade. National Trust staff and volunteers rechalking the Giant in August 2019. The Giant is usually rechalked every decade. (Image: Martin Papworth) Each of the four trenches revealed a layer cake of chalkings; in places almost a metre deep, and although the trenches were widely dispersed, the events found in each matched those in the others. Of particular interest was the discovery that the cutting filled by the lowest chunky chalk layer, cut through another, earlier scooped chalk cutting that had been the intervention that first interrupted the steep slope of the hill.

On the Friday afternoon, soil samples were collected from the earliest deposits and then transported to Gloucestershire University for dating. We had just enough time left to backfill our trenches and ram the top chalk home before it got dark. Four days later we were in lockdown across the UK and the university lab was closed. Covid meant that there would be no date supplied by the July deadline. We would have to wait until 2021 for this to be revealed.

However, Mike Allen was able to look at his samples from the dig. He discovered that snail shells, present in the lowest chalk deposits, were from species that did not exist in England during prehistoric and Roman periods. So, we began to think that the Giant was indeed a 17th-century creation representing someone like Oliver Cromwell or William III who had both been associated with the hero Hercules.

The Giant's left elbow trench looking north, showing the layers of chalkings. The Giant's left elbow trench looking north, showing the layers of chalkings. (Image: Martin Papworth) Eventually, the OSL dates came back, and they were a complete surprise. Mike favoured a prehistoric date and I the 17th century, but all four samples gave medieval dates for the silts sealing the original scoop into chalk bedrock. The two earliest ranged between AD 650- AD1110, with a 10th century median date.

The Cerne Giant story has now been shifted to the Saxon period and coincides with the founding of Cerne Abbey in 987. The Saxon historians are creating new narratives, but there is still no consensus.

Personally, I like to think of him as the abbey’s founding saint, King Edmund’s brother Eadwald; his outstretched arm carved into the hillside to guide pilgrims from Sherborne as they approached the newly built Cerne Abbey.

And another thing. He has a belt. Did he wear trousers originally? Was his most famous feature a 17th century addition? The Cerne Giant is still a mystery, open to all sorts of interpretations.

 

Further Reading:

Allen, M. (Ed.) 2020, A Date with the Two Cerne Giants, Reinvestigating an Iconic British Hill Figure (The National Trust Excavations 2020), Windgather Press

The Path of the Giant is the daily blog of the 2020 excavation, find it at: archaeologynationaltrustsw.wordpress.com/2020/03/19/the-path-to-the-giant/